Okay, so I took almost a month to actually post this... but I did indeed pick a winner from the comments left on this post!
Because there were only two comments, I decided to go with odd vs even, with commenter 1 being odd and commenter 2 being even (makes sense, right?). And the winner is:
Brad Jaeger! I'll be contacting you via email to figure out how to get your gift card to you. Congratulations!
And even though there weren't a lot of comments to choose from, it was fun for me to have a little contest, so expect to see more in the future. Any suggestions for a good reason for a contest?